Is Your EDC a Worthless Talisman?

By Steve Tarani

Posted in
#Skills

Editor’s Note: The following article is not intended as legal advice and represents the opinion of the author. Consult all applicable federal, state and local laws.

Everybody knows that there are many places where you cannot carry a firearm — even if you’re licensed — like federal buildings (USPS, courthouse, etc.), airports, schools, hospitals and posted businesses.

While you may have a fully capable EDC pistol and the skills to use it, what if you find yourself in a situation where you can’t employ it? What’s your backup plan?

Given a no-gun-carry scenario, the question arises: In lieu of your primary self-defense tool — the firearm, is your next best option to carry a knife (if legally applicable)? If so, then what are the real-world practical considerations of carrying a blade for self-defense?

Faulty Assumptions

When it comes to carrying a gun, an inexperienced gun owner might believe in their heart that their firearm will act as a talisman — a lucky charm that will ward off all evil. These same people might also no clue that owning such a life-saving tool necessitates life-saving training. The same applies to an edged tool. If you elect to carry one for self-defense, then you must also consider training.

A dramatic photograph captures a defensive scenario where one person confronts an armed attacker wielding a knife in close proximity. EDC training must include edged weapon defense scenarios. Everyday carry preparation involves understanding bad-breath distance encounters. Concealed carry weapons cannot always be accessed during surprise attacks. EDC knife defense requires recognition of seven lethal strike zones. Every day carry of ccw includes awareness of rapid threat escalation. Self-defense training addresses extreme close-quarters combat realities. EDC practitioners face exponentially increased injury risk with blades. Everyday carry mindset preparation includes willingness to engage contact weapons. — If an engagement’s distance collapses to arm’s length, your CCW skills and mental preparation get tested in ways most people never consider.

The firearm, when appropriately (legally and safely) carried, and if you are trained, can be a very effective tool in stopping attackers in a life-threatening situation. The same applies to a knife. The very same core considerations applied to firearms carry apply directly to carrying a blade. Such considerations should include your preparation in personal, legal and practical application.

Mentally Prepared

Are you prepared mentally to apply lethal use of force? In other words, do your personal beliefs, ethics and morals permit you to cause bodily harm and even death to another human being?

A photograph displays a Springfield Armory Ronin 1911 pistol positioned alongside a tactical folding knife on a neutral background. EDC firearms require complementary backup tools for restricted environments. Everyday carry systems balance pistol accessibility with knife deployment speed. Concealed carry weapons like the Ronin provide standoff engagement capability. EDC knife selection considers blade length and local legal restrictions. Every day carry of ccw involves understanding prohibited carry locations. Self-defense tools must occupy available body real estate efficiently. EDC preparation requires training with both firearms and edged weapons. Everyday carry effectiveness depends on rapid access under stress conditions. — Your everyday carry isn’t complete with just one defensive tool. Combining a 1911-style CCW like the Ronin with an edged backup means you’re prepared wherever you are.

In the case of a gun, you can apply force at a non-contact distance from the threat. A knife is a different story. The knife can only be applied at extreme close quarters, where your hand is connected to your blade, which is connected to another human being. This unfolds rapidly at bad-breath distance while applying your blade to a lethal strike zone on the body of another human being.

Legally Prepared

What are the knife carry laws in your state and county? Knife laws differ from state to state and even in some counties within your state. You can go online to reputable sources to check yours. You need to be aware of knife ownership and carry laws addressing blade length, opening mechanism (switchblades, assists, partial assists, etc.), and carry method — open (clip showing on a folder) or concealed (neck carry, inside pocket, etc.), and the like.

An intense photograph captures the violent reality of a close-quarters knife attack with a large blade threatening at arm's length. EDC training must address realistic attack distances and speeds. Everyday carry preparation involves understanding contact weapon engagement dynamics. Concealed carry weapons require sufficient reaction time for effective deployment. EDC scenarios frequently unfold at bad-breath distance ranges. Every day carry of ccw demands training beyond static range practice. Self-defense encounters with blades happen faster than firearm draws. EDC practitioners face immediate threat assessment under extreme stress. Everyday carry competence requires muscle memory developed through repetitive training. — While you might have the skills needed with your EDC pistol, do you have what it takes to handle a “knife fight”?

Be advised about purchasing a knife marketed as a “widow maker” or “black death” or “ninja killer” et al., because if you do use it to save your bacon and it ends up in court, prosecutors will present it all to a jury likely far less educated on knife carry than you.

Practically Prepared

Like a gun, if you need to stop the threat, there are specific anatomical targets in which the defensive shooter is trained to stop a lethal threat. Using a knife in self-defense is no different. Quite different in actual application than a firearm, there are seven lethal strike zones on the human body susceptible to a blade edge.

In the world of knife defense, there is an adage that has been around since the first knife was used in personal combat: “If you’re going to get into a fight with a knife, you’re going to get cut.” Compared to a firearm, due to the proximity of physical engagement, your odds of getting cut are exponentially increased. Employed as a contact weapon, fighting at extreme close quarters with an edged weapon will most likely end up on the ground if you don’t immediately vacate the threat area.

A photograph displays a Flat Dark Earth Springfield Hellcat micro-compact pistol positioned next to a tactical folding knife on a clean surface. EDC firearms benefit from compact dimensions for daily concealment. Everyday carry systems require balancing firepower with practical portability. Concealed carry weapons like the Hellcat maximize capacity in minimal footprint. EDC knife pairing provides backup options for restricted locations. Every day carry of ccw involves optimizing limited body real estate. Self-defense tools must remain accessible throughout daily activities. EDC effectiveness depends on consistent carry rather than occasional transport. Everyday carry preparation demands training with actual carry configuration. — Compact EDC setups like this FDE Hellcat, paired with a folder, provide serious capability without consuming all your carry space.

The similarities between carrying a knife and a firearm are identical with respect to carry, access, rapid deployment, and practical application. Where you carry on your body must be readily accessible by either hand. Additionally, there is also no free lunch — there is always an exchange. The body has only so much available real estate. A fixed blade, which is always faster in deployment, requires a sheath, which takes up more space. A folder, which takes up less space, requires an additional move to get the blade into service.

Conclusion

Whether it’s a gun or a knife, the truth remains unchanged: the tool is never the whole answer — you are. Your judgment, your preparation, your willingness to train, and your ability to act under extreme duress are what determine your survival. A blade clipped in your pocket or an AIWB pistol does not make you safer; only confidence and competent skill can do that.

If you choose to carry an edged tool where a firearm is prohibited and a knife is not, then you are equally charged with carrying the same responsibility. Because should it go down for real — and it happens fast — you will not rise to the level of your hopes. You will fall to the level of your most recent training.

Editor’s Note: Please be sure to check out The Armory Life Forum, where you can comment about our daily articles, as well as just talk guns and gear. Click the “Go To Forum Thread” link below to jump in!

Read the full article here