Close Menu
Truth Republican
  • Home
  • News
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Guns & Gear
  • Healthy Tips
  • Prepping & Survival
  • Videos
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
Truth Republican
  • Home
  • News
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Guns & Gear
  • Healthy Tips
  • Prepping & Survival
  • Videos
Newsletter
Truth Republican
You are at:Home»News»Karen Read’s silence in murder trial raises stakes for defense
News

Karen Read’s silence in murder trial raises stakes for defense

Buddy DoyleBy Buddy DoyleJune 4, 2025No Comments5 Mins Read
Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr WhatsApp
Karen Read’s silence in murder trial raises stakes for defense
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

Join Fox News for access to this content

Plus special access to select articles and other premium content with your account – free of charge.

By entering your email and pushing continue, you are agreeing to Fox News’ Terms of Use and Privacy Policy, which includes our Notice of Financial Incentive.

Please enter a valid email address.

Having trouble? Click here.

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles!

Karen Read’s defense team’s decision to not call her to the witness stand is a gamble that could help or hinder her case after the prosecution played her damaging interview clips in her second murder trial – allowing the jury to hear Read’s version of events in her own words. 

Read is facing the possibility of life in prison for the alleged murder of her boyfriend, Boston police officer John O’Keefe. The prosecution claims Read struck O’Keefe with her Lexus SUV in a drunken argument, leaving him to freeze to death in the front yard of a friend’s house party shortly after midnight on Jan. 29, 2022. 

Read’s defense team insists her vehicle never made contact with O’Keefe and there was no collision. 

“When I first came to practice, it was ‘never put your client on stand, ever,’” New York City defense attorney Louis Gelormino told Fox News Digital. “But I tend to disagree with that sometimes. I think we have gotten our biggest wins when we put our client on the stand.” 

KAREN READ’S TRUE-CRIME DOCUMENTARIES MAY IMPACT SECOND TRIAL: COURT DOCS

On Tuesday, the defense submitted the team’s proposed jury instructions that indicate Read will not take the stand in her trial. 

“As you know, Ms. Read did not testify at this trial,” the instructions read. “You may not hold that against her. Ms. Read has an absolute right not to testify because, as I’ve explained, she is presumed to be innocent and does not have to do anything to convince you she is innocent.” 

The instructions stress that the reason Read chose to not take the witness stand is not relevant to the jury’s deliberations and cannot be considered evidence in her trial. Legal experts tell Fox News Digital the choice to keep a defendant from speaking may not always be the best choice. 

KAREN READ, ACCUSED KILLER OF COP BOYFRIEND, SHOWED NO EMOTION UNTIL JURY DELIBERATIONS: DOCUMENTARY

A close-up of Karen Read smiling next to John O'Keefe wearing a white backwards hat.

Gelormino said he believes Read would put on a strong performance on the witness stand, but calling her to testify does not come without risks. 

“I think the reason they’re hiding her is because they don’t want to have to have her explain all these videos that they saw of her not acting in a good way,” Gelormino said.

KAREN READ JUDGE BLOCKS SANDRA BIRCHMORE MENTIONS; EXPERT SAYS CASES SHOULD BE WAKE-UP CALL FOR POLICE

Karen Read and her defense team in court at the retrial as she faces charges in connection to the death of John O'Keefe.

Special prosecutor Hank Brennan played numerous clips from Read’s televised interviews, picking out clips that could potentially damage the defense.

“I also wonder, did I say, ‘could I have hit him,’” Read said in a 2024 interview with Investigation Discovery. “Or was it told to me that I said I hit him. And I knew I never could’ve said that, so the closest thing I must’ve said was, ‘did I hit him?’”

In the clip, Read questions if she “really [said] it as many times as law enforcement is claiming.” 

KAREN READ DEFENSE FLOATS THEORY THAT ‘JEALOUS’ BRIAN HIGGINS FOUGHT JOHN O’KEEFE BEFORE DEATH

WATCH: Karen Read gives firsthand account of night before John O’Keefe’s death

In another clip, she talked about spiking her own drinks with extra shots because they weren’t strong enough.

Gelormino said the defense team likely does not want Read to be confronted about her statements on cross-examination, possibly opening the door for days of tense questioning from the state. 

“They don’t want to have her explaining all of these misbehaviors or what people would think would be bad behavior,” Gelormino said. 

But the choice to keep Read off the stand could potentially keep her from providing an explanation for her statements in the interviews while also clarifying her side of the story. 

LEAD DETECTIVE’S TEXT MESSAGES CAST SHADOW OVER KAREN READ MURDER TRIAL 

Testimony in Karen Read's trial continues

“There are two sides of every coin,” Gelormino told Fox News Digital. “You could put her on and try to have her explain it, or you can avoid it altogether.” 

Gelormino pointed to the reality that Read could appear defensive while offering an explanation for her on-camera stories, which could shift the jury’s perception of her personality. 

“As a defense attorney, you are going to have to clean that up,” Gelormino said. “So you are going to be spending a lot of time defending your character there.” 

GET REAL-TIME UPDATES DIRECTLY ON THE TRUE CRIME HUB

Karen Read arrives at court

The videos pose a new obstacle for the defense, since they were not played in Read’s first trial last year. 

“The first jury almost convicted Read of manslaughter while operating under the influence,” retired Massachusetts Superior Court Judge and Boston College law professor Jack Lu told Fox News Digital. “That was with no defendant video statements. Here, we have many damaging statements, and maybe a few more in rebuttal.” 

FOLLOW THE FOX TRUE CRIME TEAM ON X

Lu said the defense has not attempted to address the video clips or provide context regarding Read’s version of events at this point in the trial. 

“So, the same trial plus the damaging video, where the jury almost convicted, is bad for the defense,” Lu said. 

As the defense continues calling witnesses, the notable absence of Read’s own testimony will likely only be fully felt once the jury reads its verdict, with the prosecution acting as the only side that opted to include her own words in the courtroom.  

“Based on the fact that they had a hung jury the last time, [the defense has] a decent case,” Gelormino told Fox News Digital. “So do you want to mess that up with having her defend her actions and character for the next two or three days on the stand? That’s a tough decision.” 



Read the full article here

Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
Previous ArticleM1A Air Rifle Review
Next Article House Republicans push for spending cancellations as Elon Musk and conservatives demand deeper budget cuts

Related Articles

Former CBS anchor warns Paramount merger marks ‘the end’ of the network and ‘honest’ journalism

Former CBS anchor warns Paramount merger marks ‘the end’ of the network and ‘honest’ journalism

July 28, 2025
Could Senator Adam Schiff really go to jail over alleged mortgage fraud?

Could Senator Adam Schiff really go to jail over alleged mortgage fraud?

July 28, 2025
Multiple people killed in mass shooting incident at Bangkok market: police

Multiple people killed in mass shooting incident at Bangkok market: police

July 28, 2025
Yankees place Aaron Judge on 10-day IL as slugger avoids worst

Yankees place Aaron Judge on 10-day IL as slugger avoids worst

July 28, 2025
Bubba Wallace makes NASCAR history with thrilling Brickyard 400 victory at Indianapolis

Bubba Wallace makes NASCAR history with thrilling Brickyard 400 victory at Indianapolis

July 28, 2025
Florida county school board chair deletes comments celebrating Hulk Hogan’s death as ‘one less MAGA’

Florida county school board chair deletes comments celebrating Hulk Hogan’s death as ‘one less MAGA’

July 28, 2025
Brutal downtown brawl leaves victims bloodied as Cincinnati police launch investigation

Brutal downtown brawl leaves victims bloodied as Cincinnati police launch investigation

July 28, 2025
Black Sabbath bassist remembers ‘frail’ Ozzy Osbourne in heartbreaking account of rock legend’s final show

Black Sabbath bassist remembers ‘frail’ Ozzy Osbourne in heartbreaking account of rock legend’s final show

July 28, 2025
Secret Service thwarts potential threat near Trump’s White House grounds with rapid response

Secret Service thwarts potential threat near Trump’s White House grounds with rapid response

July 28, 2025
Don't Miss
World’s most premature baby defies all medical odds to reach 1st birthday

World’s most premature baby defies all medical odds to reach 1st birthday

Former CBS anchor warns Paramount merger marks ‘the end’ of the network and ‘honest’ journalism

Former CBS anchor warns Paramount merger marks ‘the end’ of the network and ‘honest’ journalism

SEN RAND PAUL: There are 6 billion reasons why we must audit the Fed

SEN RAND PAUL: There are $186 billion reasons why we must audit the Fed

Could Senator Adam Schiff really go to jail over alleged mortgage fraud?

Could Senator Adam Schiff really go to jail over alleged mortgage fraud?

Latest News
The Shocking Truth About the .38 Special – What They Don’t Tell You!

The Shocking Truth About the .38 Special – What They Don’t Tell You!

July 28, 2025
Ammo Made for Long-Term Storage Stockpiling

Ammo Made for Long-Term Storage Stockpiling

July 28, 2025
Yankees place Aaron Judge on 10-day IL as slugger avoids worst

Yankees place Aaron Judge on 10-day IL as slugger avoids worst

July 28, 2025
BREAKING: California’s Gun Law Just Got EXPOSED in Court – You Won’t Believe What Happened!

BREAKING: California’s Gun Law Just Got EXPOSED in Court – You Won’t Believe What Happened!

July 28, 2025
Bubba Wallace makes NASCAR history with thrilling Brickyard 400 victory at Indianapolis

Bubba Wallace makes NASCAR history with thrilling Brickyard 400 victory at Indianapolis

July 28, 2025
Copyright © 2025. Truth Republican. All rights reserved.
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of use
  • Contact

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.